top of page
iStock-2176963001-Extended.jpg

Finding the Best Surrogacy Agency: How to Compare Your Options

With 20 years of experience, Donor Concierge searches a broad network of trusted surrogacy agencies to find a surrogate who meets your criteria — a match within two months through our Basic program.

iStock-2176963001-Extended_edited.jpg
iStock-2277292573_edited.png

Three Ways to Find a Surrogate

Once you’ve decided on surrogacy, the next question is how you’ll find a surrogate — and you have three options: you can use a surrogacy agency, search independently, or work with a search service.

 

Donor Concierge is the third. We search across a broad network of trusted surrogacy agencies to find a surrogate who meets your specific criteria and present a candidate whose records our in-house team has reviewed. We stay with you through your clinic's review and the match call, until your surrogate has medical clearance. 

 

We’ve helped 5,000+ families find the right donor or surrogate. Our recommendations are driven by your criteria, not by referral fees.

Asset 3_10x-faded.png

Why a Single-Agency Approach Limits Your Search

When you search through one surrogacy agency, you can only consider the candidates in its current pool. If the right surrogate is not available, your timeline may depend on when a suitable candidate enters the program.

​

To expand your options, you may need to contact several agencies, manage multiple conversations, and track each agency’s process on your own. Even then, each agency moves at its own pace, and you’re the one keeping every conversation moving.

​

Donor Concierge expands your search beyond a single pool. We search across the full network, confirm availability, and identify candidates who meet your specific criteria.

How Traditional Surrogacy Agencies Work

A surrogacy agency recruits and screens surrogates, then finds a match between you and a candidate in its program. The agency supports you and your surrogate from matching through the post-birth process, assisting with communication, legal agreements, and logistics.

GettyImages-1137311153.jpg

What an Independent Surrogate Search Involves

An independent surrogate search means finding a surrogate through personal connections or online platforms rather than a traditional agency. You gain direct control over the search and the relationship.

Asset 3_10x-faded.png

You also take on everything an agency would otherwise handle: finding legal counsel, coordinating medical evaluations and travel, managing communication between all parties, and confirming the surrogate meets your clinic’s screening requirements.

How Donor Concierge Works

Your dedicated case manager runs the search, screens each candidate against your criteria and your clinic’s requirements, and presents one surrogate who meets them. We handle the communication with each agency. Once you confirm a match, we coordinate the handoff to the agency you choose and stay in communication with the agency through medical clearance.

Step 1_Icon.jpg

Step 1

Search

We search the network and our in-house medical records team reviews candidates against ASRM guidelines and your clinic's requirements. Only candidates who clear that review, and who are available and ready to start, come to you.

57abf6f1-4e88-46c5-8c7e-e854ed1f8ccc.png

Step 2

Review

You receive one pre-approved candidate's profile. If she's a fit, we contact her agency and arrange a video call so you can meet her before any financial commitment.

2975cb1a-29ab-43c4-b72e-4c1aa7a5c508.png

Step 3

Confirm the Match

After the call, your clinic reviews her medical records. Once they approve, you and the surrogate each confirm within 24 hours. You sign the agency agreement, and we stay in communication with the agency through medical clearance.

Comparing Your Three Surrogacy Service Options

  • Access to one agency’s surrogate pool

  • Match time depends on who is available in that agency's pool

  • Manages screening, legal, and medical processes

  • Extensive support throughout the journey

  • Protocols in place to mitigate risks and handle complications

Traditional Agency

If the candidates you‘ve seen so far haven’t met your criteria, tell us what you’re looking for and we’ll search the network for the right one.

Surrogacy Without Agency

  • Limited choices through personal networks and online communities

  • Match times can vary widely

  • Requires self-management

  • Limited support

  • Higher personal risk without professional oversight

  • A broad network of trusted surrogacy agencies, not one agency's roster

  • A defined search window — a match within two months through our Basic program

  • Manages the search and pre-approval stage — everything before you sign with an agency

  • Active support through search and pre-approval; case manager available through your surrogate's medical clearance

  • Candidates reviewed by our in-house medical records team against ASRM guidelines and your clinic's requirements, before you commit to an agency

Donor Concierge

When a Concierge Surrogacy Service Makes the Most Sense

A concierge surrogate search makes the most sense when the candidate pool at a single agency isn't meeting your criteria. We search every agency in our network at the same time, instead of leaving you to work through them one at a time.

​​If you’re working within a timeline, the search runs to a defined window rather than to another agency's intake schedule — a match within two months through our Basic program.

​

That leaves you one decision to make: whether the surrogate we present is right for you.

Choosing the Right Surrogacy Path for You

The right approach depends on how much of the process you want to manage, how specific your criteria are, and how quickly you need to move.

If your priority is

The stronger fit is

Specific criteria a single agency has not met

Concierge search — broader network, one candidate presented at a time

End-to-end coordination from search through birth

Traditional agency — manages screening, legal, and medical processes throughout

Knowing what you'll spend before you commit

Concierge search — a one-time flat fee, and no large agency fees until you've confirmed the match

The lowest possible cost, and full control of the process

Independent searching — requires significant self-management

Tell Us What You're Looking For in a Surrogate

We have helped more than 5,000 families since 2006

“[Dynamic Testimonal from Collection]”

Quote Caption

trustlogo-od_edited.png
bottom of page